This song is tight!

The video was so well done
they resemble each other so much, you can't tell who's who.

I thought the song would suck, but it's really nice.

Plus Beyonce made a video for each song on her B-day album
today the "Upgrade U" video was premiered and it was cool

I love that song, that and "Freakum Dress" are my favs.

I wanna see the Get Me Bodied video.

I saw the video, and I wasn't that impressed. I used to like Shakira And Beyoncé, but not so much now. They should go back to their olden days.

it was alright...nothing to shout about.

altho i have to say that i think Beyonce was feeling the heat from Shakira's last performance which is prolly why she wanted her on the same track..you know keeping her competition in her sights...because..its so obvious how she's tryna look like her in the vid...Shakira stood out to me anyhow.

i like the dance break. that was hot.

IMO they could've done alot better, song and video.

it was ok i didnt really like it im not a fan of shakiras voice..

It's not the best song

but its soooo much better than what I expected

I thought it was gunna be a load of crap.

i love it, and i think they both did a good job in the vid. to me personally beyonce rocked, i mean she's just got it natural to her. shakira didn't really show her full potential though because she can move beyond in that vid.

i heard the song before i saw the video ..and at first it was just whatever to me ..but i i started liking it a lot cause of the lyrics and i just thought they made a hot duo ...and i really did love the video ..i was surprised because i don't really like anything Beyonces been doing >_<

I like Shakira pre"blond"... Yeah I said it, she doing rock before she became all "my boobs are nimble" blah blah blah. I'll give her this though; she's great live.

Beyonce can just bounce for all I care. She's nothing without Destiny's Child..... NOTHING!!

woah
the video is just woah

Shakira looked HOT !

beyonce looked ok,body seemed less nice compared to shakiras

lol Me too! Although, Whenever Wherever was pretty good. She was much better in the album Donde Estan Los Ladrones. That's my favorite album of hers.

good song name,

bad video + boring song! - - - -

i just saw the video and i thought it was nice and i do like the song too.
also i just saw the upgrade u video...it was ok i guess.

This was an awesome collaboration ^__^

I didn't like the video cuz it seemed really... cheap >_>''
It seemed like Beyounce was trying to copy Shakira's bellydance moves @_@' kinda annoying, it would've been better if she did her own thing

I found this to be shocking at first xD it was seriously a unexpected collab, but it resulted to be a good song

surprisingly, I've got to say, the collab between the two was unexpectingly OK...

definitely an awesome collab
the music video is ANNOYING. i think Shakira looked sooooo much better in the mv than Beyonce

the most thing I liked was the dancing...then again they are both good dancers and could have done something more. but hey. U gotta litsten 2 the some more than once b4 u like it lol.

I think the whole concept was to have them look like each other and have it be confusing and all.

I did like it, but Shakira was just on the whole better, because Beyonce is getting a little tired.

The dancing was pretty good but I think it's one of those songs that I have to let grow on me for a while...