Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Edward Cullen Or Jacob Black
soompi forums > soompi entertainment > other tv, movies, & books
Pages: 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6
belle_kd1413
^
DUDE.GRAMMAR CHECK.

Bella deserves , well...the main-girl k?, the best.
EDWARD= THE BEST.
eneri04
TEAM EDWARD all the way! biggrin.gif
yea, i'm for edward.
like an icon i saw in the internet.
"TEAM EDWARD cause jacob doesn't sparkle" XD
spuddevaughn
I'm still for Edward all the way baby!! I know some people think that he is overbearing but his good traits overshadow some of his flaws..it just makes him better because he is not really that perfect and he knows that as well.
LionAngel
i liked jacob T___T
but edward and bella have more chemistry smile.gif
orange.xin.wo
EDWARDCULLEN!!

He respects Bella's opinion. He doesn't push her to like him more than the other. In fact, he would rather her NOT like him, just to keep her safe. Unlike Jacob, would just pretty much tells her "I'm the better on. Love me more."
At least that's how i see it..
dianalikesbutts
JACOB BLACK <333333
ginger
I'm in the vast minority, but I chose Jacob.


Edward: "liquid topaz eyes", "velvet voice", "marble chest", yadda yadda. He's over-protective (giving Bella a ridiculous car, not allowing her to make decisions for herself), patronizing, self-sacrificing, always the "better man", beautiful, fast, strong, smart. So why don't I like Edward? He's boring AS CRAP. I can't believe that so many girls are infatuated with this one-dimensional, bland, poorly-developed character. He's so stereotypical that, when I read it, I pretty much lost all respect for Meyer as a writer. He's basically...the "WHAT NOT TO WRITE" for those of us who have earned degrees in literature/creative writing.

Jacob was amusing, at least. Edward? Boring as hell. Gee, I wonder what he's going to do next? Be chivalrous and kind? Be self-sacrificing? REALLY? *sarcastic* Wow, what a surprise...not.

-ginger
cute girl
of course no one can beat Edward Cullen..
LaTinky
edward edward edward .... ONE GAZILLION TIMES EDWARD!!! ♥
they're too perfect together
weird&short
i pick... Spike! hehe he's a cool guy... I like him better than those two >_<
l3lo
cool laugh.gif why didn't i think of this? lol with all those other Harry or Edward threads no one thought of "Edward or Jacob"? lol funny...anyways i voted for Jacob and saw the results...it made me sad tears.gif but i'll still stand by Jacob. whoot, whoot i got your back "JAKE!" lol! i don't know why but Edward never really got to me even in the beginning. i felt no connection like the other readers. but for some reason Jacob had me laugh.gif.
Melyxcious
Jacob amused me in Breaking Dawn while Edward annoyed me whenever I think back to how he was and whatnot.
Sure, he's perfect and all, but... seriously, perfection is boring.

JACOB<3




then again, I CHOOSE EMMETT CUZ HE BE HOT LIKE THAT HAHA.
shinnini
still voted for edward..go TEAM EDWARD!!!! wink.gif
Jnn
QUOTE (Melyxcious @ Sep 23 2008, 05:19 PM) *
Jacob amused me in Breaking Dawn while Edward annoyed me whenever I think back to how he was and whatnot.
Sure, he's perfect and all, but... seriously, perfection is boring.

JACOB<3

Agreed.

Jacob is so cute and funny and exciting, he obviously cares for Bella a lot, and puts in so much effort. Edward is amazing and perfect, but too dominating and while Bella enjoys it..i think he's too suffocating. XD
touchthesky
bella and edward suit each other better but i definitely like jacob more. i was on team edward in the beginning but he totally annoyed me in BD. plus i feel like i don't know much about him besides his broad marble chest. jacob can be annoying but he's more well rounded and human.
Autumne
Neither? Both of them annoy me to no end. But I'll go with Jacob since he annoys me less. biggrin.gif
Shiget^
TEAM EDWARD ALL THE WAY XDDDDDD

Jacob is boring, i dont feel anything for him ROFLLLLLL bella and edward have great chemistry XDD
boa258
EDWARD ALL THE WAY !
jacob is kinda of annoying...
Scribbled
Jacob, hands down. Even though I don't like the Twilight Saga.

Warmth, wit, sarcasm. (:
hayuna
Jacob.

Edward bores me.
lntervention
Edward, because he sparkles.
Enough said haha smile.gif

SMeyer killed every character's appeal by like 75% in BD though.
bAbystAr_jjUngg
i've never read the series, but i love taylor lautner, the guy who plays jacob black, so my vote goes to him<3
but as far as i know, a lot more of my friends are in love with the edward character XD
pga pga
I always feel bad for the other guy lol

so yea jacob but edward is fine too XD

strawberrii chuuu


edward is perfection.
i would love to meet a real guy like him

Minnie-chan
ahaha I'm one of the few Jacob fans I guess? ahaha
iono why but I loved Edward in book 1 but his personality is a bit too um...perfect which I find boring ^^;;
Jacob is funny and full of surprises ahaha
annie_bananie
TEAM EDWARD! wink.gif

i like Jacob but there's something about him.... ohmy.gif
min_60
EDward FTW!!!

For some unknown reason, Jacob is sometimes very annoying
baoi
team edward. He's irresistible!
chjp
Of course
Edward and Bella!
*.:AnGeL*BAbII:.*
TEAM EDWARD ! biggrin.gif
jacob is just annoying... and he has his own match....tongue.gif
chap.pie
When I first read the Twilight saga I was sold on Edward. But then last week I reread it again just for fun, and realized I like Jacob lol xDD So it's FUR OVER FANGS FOR ME ^^o
PerniciousJuJu
Edward is sooo much hotter!! He's clam and it's sexy! and when he's angry and frustrated it's cute!

I love edward cullen!!
AiMango
edward ftw. i really disliked jacob until.. book 2 of breaking dawn. reading his thoughts wasnt so bad. and even thuogh he did crazy things to bella in eclipse, it was reasonable. people kept telling me jacob would be such a jerk in eclipse. bella belongs to edward, though. i like reading exb more than jxb, so..
princess
Im with team Edward Cullen i dont really like Jacob Black to me he
seemed to be a bad person later in the story and i personally think
Edward and Bella makes a better couple also i love how Edward is
very hard to understand it makes him more mysterious and sexy in
a way just my opinion
laugh.gif
♥♥PowerOf9
TEAM EDWARD!! <3
I don't like Jacob haha tongue.gif
sweetcandies
eh i feel like jacob is too immature for bella. bella's like a middle-aged at heart like stephenie meyer described. sooo
team edward
edward and bella were simply made for each other PERIOD (:
intenseninja
Team Edward....
but Jacob is soo sweet to Bella in New Moon....
i wanna say bothh...can i ?
xboleex
Edward Cullen ftw~
i love Edward <3
Miss Bouakham
who's better for bella...well, if i put myself in her shoes, i'd go for edward

i mean, i love jacob's character and all, but to me, he'll just always be a great friend and son-in-law laugh.gif tongue.gif
Gummi Bear
I couldn't imagine anybody else for Bella except Edward. Running to my closet to put my Team Edward T-shirt on!!!
FESHA
QUOTE (lyrical lies @ Sep 13 2008, 10:56 PM) *
oh, but Jacob is a strong wolf. smile.gif he's no longer a pup (;



i agree with you! i didn't really care much for Jacob before. in book 3 i found him quite amusing, but i was too into edward then. then i realized edward was pretty boring. don't kill me D: i loved him in book one, but he changed alot after he met bella. he used to be so mysterious, and dangerous when he decided he was breaking all the rules, but after that he was all too cautious. but jacob stayed funny, sweet, and witty throughout. i loved the relationship between bella and jacob, how they were so comfortable to joke around with stuff that were really touchy topics. "Sorry I'm late honey." man, i love jacob (:


A strong Alpha wolf actually. But I agree about Jacobs personality. I liked Edward in the first book until The New Moon he left Bella. Got sad and later got mad after words. I liked Jacob.

Ah! Hands Edward to Bella and keeps Jacob.
.alyak_
Edward Team all the way. Main reason = Robert! LOL=)
jae+ut4eva
TEAM EDWARD all the way~
no one else
JACOB was perfect, but EDWARD came along and u just cant change that
no matter what.xD
BUT i still LOVE Jacob,,
just for Bella, it will always be Edward so long as he's there
mo.NeMo81
edward. in the series I was pretty annoyed by jacob as much as he is outgoing, i find that he is a taddd too immature. edward later in the series became a man and less 'overprotective' of bella and still is perfect happy.gif.
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2009 Invision Power Services, Inc.