Nigel Lythgoe, from So You Think You Can Dance


Simon Cowell, from American Idol


Ron Fair, from Search for the Next Doll


Janice Dickinson, from America's Next Top Model

I'm talking about Judges, not hosts like Ramsay from Hell's Kitchen, or New York from ILNY, etc...

HAHA man it's a tie between simon cowell and janice dickinson
but i think rudest has to be janice.. atleast simon's criticism is accurate..

janice dickenson is the rudest judge i've ever seen.

I have to say Janice Dickinson. I can see a soft spot in Simon Cowell, but in Janice? She is straight up rude.

^Agree. At least Simon's criticism is constructive and accurate.

oh yeah. definitely janice.

Janice of course. But she does have a heart when she saw the girl crying because of her acne problems. If you watch her agency show and they were looking for models in her own agency with acne problems, this girl wanted it so bad she was crying infront of her. She felt really bad and helped her out.

but in the antm, yeah she is very harsh, but she makes the show more lively and fun. She was hilarious and she was one of the reason for me to watch antm because of her rude comments.

Funny you talk about the acne problem, because in ANTM....

Janice: Do you have a little skin problem?
Yaya: It's a menstrual break out.
Janice: AHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH!

video: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YEkPw6CasuI

Janice, but she does it on purpose to be funny. and I never thought Simon was that bad; everything he says is true

leongfun:

oh yeah i remember that one. But the one in her agency show u should watch it. She really was nice and wanted to help her models out.

Does Judge Judy count?

No, those are two different type of judges, lol..

i chose simon cus i dunno who janice is. but ron is not rude at all.

Janice dickinson for sure but simon is right behind

I REALLY REALLY REALLY hate Janice Dickinson. Seriously, every time I see her on America's Next Top Model I literally want to pull my eyes out and kick my TV in. She's so mean and she thinks that she's a super great model (and she's not), I really can't stand her. >:/

Simon isn't 'rude', he's blunt. The thing is, he tells it like it is. When Simon says something and people get mad, I'm just like "Well SOMEONE had to say it..."


Janice Dickinson, on the otherhand, is just an out-right b****. I can't agree with her much of the time. She just says things to be mean, and she plays favourites so easily. I can't stand anything about her.

I personally think that the rudest judge on television is that judge from America's Got Talent. Everything he says is rude and not even close to being constructive. It's like he's trying to be a character.


This guy! Piers Morgan.



On the other note, my favorite judge is Nigel Lythgoe. He seems to genuinely care about the contestants and is the most constructive. He may have opinions differing from everyone else, but everything he says is to help the dancers better and I love it. He doesn't seem like he's trying to be mean to just be a character. He's just him. =)

I hate him!! He was a judge on Britain's Got Talent alongside Simon Cowell and everytime Piers would say something nasty (when he clearly didn't have a clue what he was talking about) the audience would shout, "Who are you? Who are you? Who are you?" He tries to be somebody he isn't (even though both personas come across as complete a-holes) and nobody really likes him.

But out of the judges listed I would have to go with Janice too. I don't watch America's Next Top Model but have seen like one episode and she's just horrible to try and be funny, whereas when Simon does it he's hilarious anyway and actually tells the truth and knows what he's talking about. He also knows how far to push it too.

Never heard of Piers Morgan, haha.

Janice Dickinson is a Richard. Yeah, that's what she is D<

I think he's just being humorous xD

well idk much judges .. so i'll go with simon
but mann janice is one b--ch

~oh, I forgot about that piers morgan guy!
i know him by face but not by name and i still dont know he really is.
was he some kind of producer that's why he got to be a judge? sorry, dont have a clue *shrugs

Janice is hilarious BUT straight up rude (in both her modeling agency and ANTM)
while Simon he's blunt and that's the way he is.