~This is following up my last question.
QUOTE
If the "nice guy" is the guy who treats girls nice, the one you can talk to, blah blah blah...so why isn't he boyfriend material? What do those other dudes do that is so special/different?
I think I get what everyone is saying. Could you provide examples anyways? I'm kinda slow. 
She knows I like(d) her. I still do. I told her I would move on. She expects that I have. Though I haven't.
If I start to change now by "treating her special", she will know something is up. I'm not too sure if that's good or bad but I'm skeptical.
She'll probably feel weird. She's the type to be awkward around guys who like her when she doesn't like them back.
Anyways, I don't treat everyone the same. Around other girls, I'm kinda a flirt (she says), pretty mean/evil, and kinda a jerk?
For example: When I talk to girls, I'll be like "hey beautiful" or "sup sexy". I'm kinda disrespectful? When I'm talk/with her I'm more gentlemenly-like. Maybe that's why I'm the nice guy, in her eyes (if I am).
Also, I don't always say yes to her.
Anyways, I don't think its the nice guy thing. What/why else would a girl not have feelings for a guy and even worse set him into the best-friend zone?because she has girlfriends who can do the same thing. but her girlfriends wont fill her needs of love and security. and though nice guys know how to treat a girl well, they treat everyone well. i think in general, girls are selfish. when they want love, they want to know that they are especially loved. not loved because you simply love everyone. secondly, though lots of girls are up in arms about equality and independence, they still have an inner part of them that wants security/stability. they're a bit weaker emotionally. they bend faster [though guys break more often]. nice guys are like frail girls that you're afraid to hug because you might break them. says yes to everything and makes it hard to show the girl that he's got a fight in him too.
i'm sure not every girl is like this, but this generalization is applicable to an overwhelming majority. they are fully smart, capable and can do many things a man cannot, and also many things better than a man. however, there's still some mysteriousness in them that just makes them desire a sturdy guy in her life that fulfills her emotional need to be loved.
*applauds* Nicely well said! Sometimes I wonder if you are a girl... jk. Lol
What those other guys have that the nice guys don't is that they have the ability to say "No". Nice guys usually are the ones that can't say no (kind of like pushovers a bit), hence girls feel like they can walk over them like door mats. (No backbone)
Do you treat everyone (or just all girls) that way? Like, are you nice to all of them? or just one in particular?
The way I see it, if I met a nice guy who treated me (along with some other girl friends) very nicely, I would feel happy, but not special. Girls (I'm sure with guys too) like to feel special, like they're different from others. If you treat everyone the same way, they'll just think of you as a friend because you don't treat them any different than you would a friend.
You can thank WongFu Productions for that lol.

I just saw that video. Lol. I didn't get that message though.