[mingkle]

i'm sorry if i'm a little slow at this but i never knew that Justin Gaurini and Kelly Clarkson from american idol sang the song timeless from jang ri in and Xiah.



justin and kelly: http://youtube.com/watch?v=hoMs7XOQP28
jang and xiah: http://youtube.com/watch?v=eSNZ7iIl6Fk

[miyavidoll]

i found out not so long ago too..
but then i like jang ri rin and xiah's version more

[toybox]

yeah i like jang ri in and xiah's version better : )

[vivabianca]

yup yup.

but then again, if you recognized the song as being sung by Justin and Kelly first...you'd have to admit you saw From Justin, To Kelly because it's off that movie soundtrack. No offense, but SM shouldn't have chosen Jang Ri In to sing Kelly Clarkson's part. Kelly Clarkson's vocals > Jang Ri In's vocals plus her infallible ability to botch up her singing when she's nervous.

[beckyvang17]

yeah i thought that the korean vers. was a little better..
--but i still like both..very nice

=]becky

[EverCool]

I actually like Kelly Clackson and Justin's version better. I guess because I hear it first by them and to me Jang Ri In tried to sound like her too much.

[sushiieeex3]

I already knew about this since I have the movie From Justin To Kelly. Haha I got it for a birthday present. IMO, I love Kelly's voice more, although Jang Ri In sings it beautifully as well. I will admit that Xiah Junsu and Jang Ri In's version of the song sounds more passionate but Kelly's range just AMAZES me @__@

[summerdamsel]

The korean version was better for me. Yeah, its a lot more passionate.. XD So much emotions that Junsu sounded like he's crying in the first stanza XD
Kelly's range is amazing though..
I find it just strange on when I try to sing.. its much easier to reach her notes than Jang Ri In's ..

[babypink12345]

Whoa, I never knew that!
Thanks for posting it!!
Of course the Korean version is better because Justin and Kelly didn't sing it with as much passion.
But I also like the American version because now I can sing along with it!!!!

[xflyjiyong94]

*tries hardest not to be biased*
i like the korean version better.
i find it more passionate, like you can actually FEEL the song lol
but kelly's voice is so powerful...

kelly&&junsu...hmm

[lutty~]

the korean version sounds better to me.
Kelly looks so cute in that vid btw. xD

[영원한 사랑]

Kelly & Justin sing better, as in vocal ability.
I actually like their version better too.
I just don't like Jang Ri In's singing that much, sorry.

[liltickle]

I knew that once she debuted. Jang Ri In actually copy Kellys song TIMELESS and made it into a Korean VERISON!
But Jang RI In is a beautiful singer.

[R~Ny Luv K-Pop]

their voice better..
their version better too...
but i still luv xiah n jang ri in version

[smylies]

me too! i like junsu and ri in's version more. especially the mv.

[pikapika]

the mv sucks for the american version

but i liked the american vocals more

[d a y.b r e a k]

i'm more use to the korean one ahah
the american clip suk butt compare to the korean clip though ahah

-TEAA`

[xjuyonx]

agree with vivabianca... what about a kelly clarkson/xiah junsu duet? HAHA

[Indogurl05]

it would be better if junsu sing it with kelly.. jang ri in tries to hard to be like kelly.. just my 2 cents..

[crackednut]

the mv sucks for the american version

but i liked the american vocals more

its not exactly a mv since its a scene from the musical movie that they did together