[fielding]

I didn't dig their lexy performance either, I really think they don't get to pick their songs, these song choices just are not showing their true singing potential. I wonder if they pick it or the radio station? guess I won't really know haha

but awesome on becoming the tbj models! I love 4min's fashion, I'm already trying to gather some of their tights to add to my collection hahah though I've never seen tbj's past collection

[Do0mAid]

already report this post. I hope Administrator/moderator or whatever will do something..
no need to come here if you want to mention something bad to the girls. this place for 4minute fans for sharing informations and spread love to them..

I think the person was just complimenting the fans on being able to admit they didn't sound very good (which they didn't) instead of denying the obvious. They weren't putting down 4Minute (just the not so great cover eek!)

The Milkshake performance was pretty bad =/ I couldn't even watch the whole thing, because I start to feel terrible/embarrassed for them ><! The best I can say is that they tried to do it with charisma and smiled during the performance. Let's hope whoever suggested they perform the song has learned a lesson and better songs are picked in the future! It would be a shame if the person in charge started to ruin their image with bad song choices and letting them sing without adequate practice =/!

Congrats to them for getting the modeling contract! I hope it's just the beginning for them though !

[jhshinee]

already report this post. I hope Administrator/moderator or whatever will do something..
no need to come here if you want to mention something bad to the girls. this place for 4minute fans for sharing informations and spread love to them..

There was really no point in reporting that. It was constructive criticism. But theres always one to do things like this. That person didnt really bash anyone. Anyway the girl is really cute without the sunglasses. I hope eventually her role will have them off because she looks better to me without them. Im still working on who's names are who but one girl looks like sunye a bit to me. Very pretty.

[xeudaemonic]

another performance tomorrow night for mnet (: i can't waitt, ji hyun <333

[Nutshellgirl]

i just saw an article on 4-minute.com about their radio guesting http://www.4-minute.com/forums/index.php?s...amp;#entry9186..
what does THIRD CLASS mean as for Jiyoon's case?

I dont really get the context.
anyone?

and TBJ?
WOnderMinute photoshoot please.

[Eltoshen]

already report this post. I hope Administrator/moderator or whatever will do something..
no need to come here if you want to mention something bad to the girls. this place for 4minute fans for sharing informations and spread love to them..

We're not allowed to express our opinions? Since when was that ever the case? If that's the kind of topic this is, then seriously, I don't think I'd ever come back.

The Milkshake cover was comedy relief for me, nothing more. Besides the fact that the maknae sang most of it (rofl), it was really funny how they twisted the english around. Ji Hyun actually looked confused, not because she didn't know the lines, but because she wasn't sure how exactly the audience was taking it.

Well, it doesn't matter. Their Lexy cover was quite better, although not perfect. Jiyoon can rap and sing, what more can you ask?

[hellocatty]

I'm late, but I just heard Milkshake today. Definitely not their best cover, it looked messy and the only parts where they sounded good was the parts they knew which was ... not many. Ahh... they must have known that was not good they probably felt pretty bad afterwards and I'm sure they'll work on improving in the future. Yoon² cover of If I Ain't Got You was divine though.

ahhh Ji Yoon ah ~ <33333

Ahh the Lexy cover T.T even if I wasnt a huge Lexy and Ji Eun fan that cover was not so good. It wasnt as bad as Milkshake, but the chorus when they were just like YELLING I had to turn my volume off. IDK they girls looked like they were having fun but it was like they were noraebanging lol. And the girl beside Ji Yoon looked super uncomfortable.

IDK it seems like Cube has pushed these girls into a genre they are not so comfortable with (except Ji Yoon and Hyunah). Sometimes it seems like their debut was super rushed and the other girls are still very very nervous. Plus with their whirlwind activites I'm sure none of this has settled in yet.

Hot Issue was a catchy track perhaps they should try covering songs similar to that style.

Congrats for the TBJ! I love TBJ shoots they are always super cute and HQ and hugeeee.

[edward1849]

AAAAHHHH!!!

4 MINUTE ROX!

4 MINUTE ROX!

4 MINUTE ROX!

4 MINUTE ROX!

4 MINUTE ROX!

Please do not spam. Your post is meaningless.

[fielding]

I'm late, but I just heard Milkshake today. Definitely not their best cover, it looked messy and the only parts where they sounded good was the parts they knew which was ... not many. Ahh... they must have known that was not good they probably felt pretty bad afterwards and I'm sure they'll work on improving in the future. Yoon² cover of If I Ain't Got You was divine though.

ahhh Ji Yoon ah ~ <33333

Ahh the Lexy cover T.T even if I wasnt a huge Lexy and Ji Eun fan that cover was not so good. It wasnt as bad as Milkshake, but the chorus when they were just like YELLING I had to turn my volume off. IDK they girls looked like they were having fun but it was like they were noraebanging lol. And the girl beside Ji Yoon looked super uncomfortable.

IDK it seems like Cube has pushed these girls into a genre they are not so comfortable with (except Ji Yoon and Hyunah). Sometimes it seems like their debut was super rushed and the other girls are still very very nervous. Plus with their whirlwind activites I'm sure none of this has settled in yet.

Hot Issue was a catchy track perhaps they should try covering songs similar to that style.

Congrats for the TBJ! I love TBJ shoots they are always super cute and HQ and hugeeee.

I agree with everything you said here. In the end the only thing the girls can do is improve and try to work harder. I feel they can do it so I'm not concerned.

[edward1849]

I'm glad to see that the regular people in this thread are acknoledging that their recent perf. of "Milkshake" was an epic fail....

And if you're the type that's actually defending them... Damn, you got no ears....

Warned for artist bashing.

[Badboyz]

^ Lmao...
I wasn't bashing the artist, I was more like bashing the overly protective deaf fans...
Truth remains, perf. was a complete fiasco...

[Nutshellgirl]

Milkshake..
The english is really not good..we all know that.
But the vocals are okay.

Love the cute Maknae on that vid.
she is really a charming girl.

[ohnins]

I don't think there's a need to report Badboyz.
Even though his comments are a bit harsh on fans,
i don't find it offensive...imo.

Honestly, i'm always afraid to post comments up in soompi
because you'll never know you can be reported for something
people don't agree on.

Let's make this a more friendlier thread. be a bit less sensitive?
*i really hope i won't bashed for this ohmyg*

---xoxo---

Looks like CUBE is behind all this mess.
They really have to do something about their marketing plans
and give the girls what they need to be ready for live singing and performances.

[1234]

I'm glad to see that the regular people in this thread are acknoledging that their recent perf. of "Milkshake" was an epic fail....

And if you're the type that's actually defending them... Damn, you got no ears....

Badboyz, you can post your comments or thoughts but in a nice way. Swearing is an offensive word to hear and we got ears baby. Please we want to avoid fight here.

soompi is not like other forum, they are very strick when it comes to posting.

[1234]

We're not allowed to express our opinions? Since when was that ever the case? If that's the kind of topic this is, then seriously, I don't think I'd ever come back.

The Milkshake cover was comedy relief for me, nothing more. Besides the fact that the maknae sang most of it (rofl), it was really funny how they twisted the english around. Ji Hyun actually looked confused, not because she didn't know the lines, but because she wasn't sure how exactly the audience was taking it.

Well, it doesn't matter. Their Lexy cover was quite better, although not perfect. Jiyoon can rap and sing, what more can you ask?

we are allowed but no offensive words written, they can post their comments but in a nnice way. Badboyz comment might hurt 4minute fans and it might lead to a fight.

Upps sorry i double post. I don't know how to edit. Sorry

[lamia]

They landed TBJ!! <3

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9OAv36bBPhE...re=channel_page

I love how Appa (Jiyoon) starts eating from Omma's (Jihyun) cup thingy..lol and then all of them start taking stuff from each other.. adorable!

[Ssaga_G]

I made a picture thread for Gayoon
http://www.soompi.com/forums/index.php?showtopic=298483

You should come and support.
She seems to be the most underrated and nobody seems to really know who she is...
But I just wanna give her a little start and get her some recognition

[I<3SunSunYeMi]

they did quite ok in lexy's cover individually,they just screamed in the chorus,not a good way =\
at least i can hear their true voices,hyuna's vocal improves a lot since WG days,she just need a bit more training
2yoon are always good
there's always room for improvement
i wish they practise more if they want to sing other covers,they still have great potential

[hariaz]

ok i don't want to be bash but i have to say the truth,...4minute cover of MilkShake is totally horrible,..i even find myself turning off the volume and just quit watching but i won't blame the girls for it because as what i heard from their cover of alicia keys song they sounded pretty good,..so i think it is really the choice of song that sucks,..
hope they get better nxt tym,...

[kirra12]

the lexy one doesnt sound good cuz all5 are singing as the melody,
imo they still have yet to find their way to harmonize each other,
but they are still new, xD so its alright

sneak peak on official mnet pictures~
finally its hereeeee

Source : Mnet
Reupload : kirra12 @ 4-minute.com