[redsol]

Ew, they sing bad, i dont like they sing Tell me, not ok
Lucky Huyn A left WGS

How nice of you to waste your time to tell us that in an APPRECIATION thread

[dothat36]

i am in love with the Tell me performance finally the day when Hyuna perfomes Tell Me has come

Gajoon sang the best for me. Maknae's omona is so cute i love the triple omona

Hyuna's rap is definitely different from Yoobin lol. i love it, but i prefer her to do it with her husky rap ( like the Irony days)

4MINUTE, PERFORM IRONNYYY PLSS!!!!!!

Oh yeah.. them performing IRONY would be really hot and delicious.... wow, this one should happen <3

[Aeternium]

I don't understand why Ji Yoon didn't rap YooBin's part. Her voice was perfect for it. Hyun Ah's voice is too high pitched for that, I guess her voice really transformed and wasn't like this just for Hot Issue. Little So Hyun sung her parts perfectly.

[1234]

Ew, they sing bad, i dont like they sing Tell me, not ok
Lucky Huyn A left WGS

You are breaking the rule bashing the artist?
PLEASE IF YOU JUST BASHING 4MINUTE THIS IS NOT THE RIGHT PLACE TO DO.

[fielding]

Not my favourite performance of theirs. It was alright. Though it did bother me the leader didn't get many lines in this or..any?, or if she did, I missed it? I dunno, I'm rewatching it again to see. Jiyoon sounded good though~

[Ayuumu]

Hi!
I'm new here but have followed 4Minute since the first day!
^.^

[monmoon]

^uh oh


i am in love with the Tell me performance finally the day when Hyuna perfomes Tell Me has come

Gajoon sang the best for me. Maknae's omona is so cute i love the triple omona

Hyuna's rap is definitely different from Yoobin lol. i love it, but i prefer her to do it with her husky rap ( like the Irony days)

4MINUTE, PERFORM IRONNYYY PLSS!!!!!!

I would like that! That I would really like..Irony was like my favorite WG song and I think 4minute has 2 powerful singers who could do justice to that.

[Nakuru]

Ew, they sing bad, i dont like they sing Tell me, not ok
Lucky Huyn A left WGS

Warned for artist bashing.

[Do0mAid]

Either I'm crazy or my ears went bad, but I thought 4Minute sounded great during the "Tell Me" performance? It definitely was different from the Wonder Girls that's for sure, but it was still good!

They gave Hyun Ah the rap and not Jiyoon because when Hyun Ah was actually a Wonder Girl that WAS her part so it makes no sense to give it someone else, and they couldn't give Jiyoon a big singing part because the song is too girly, and would it would ruin her "tomboy" image, in my opinion.

As for Jihyun not getting any parts... I'm not sure why she didn't but there could be a couple reasons. One, I just want to point out that being a leader has nothing to do with singing or dancing ability. It usually has to with age first, and personality second. So just because she doesn't sing doesn't mean she's not showing leadership. As for WHY she's not singing maybe she's honestly just not good enough to sing live yet? This happens with lots of new groups. The weak singer just doesn't get many parts if any.

Examples (I'm talking about when they first debuted):

SHINee - Taemin
DBSK - Yoochun/Yunho
SNSD - Hyoyeon
etc.

I looked on Youtube for some clips of her singing but didn't find any, if anyone can prove me wrong then I take it all back!

[cjheartkpop]

So, I just watched the performance of Tell Me! It was pretty good.
I think Gayoon and Sohyun had the best vocals.
Hyunah's rap was good! she made it cute!
Jiyoon didn't sing much, but it still sounded great!
And Jihyun....the leader? why didn't she sing anything?!
Overall, it was a decent performance

[chungmah.]

Terrible capture I took but Hyunah looks cool lol
look at that 4minute ring ?

[iPanda]

Hi!
I'm new here but have followed 4Minute since the first day!
^.^

WELCOME! (:

I don't think anyone's ears went bad, I don't think it was terrible but it wasn't what I really expected. I think I need to stop having REALLY high expectations for these girls sometimes which was why I was very disappointed. I think people keep comparing them to WG's original, but if you don't and listen it to them as themselves they sound pretty good. Just kind of :l about leader not singing..

^Thanks for the picture, 4Minute ring is pretty hooooot!

[lemurturtle]

ok, i was a bit upset with the tell me performance.
how could they give hyuna most of the verses AND the rap .
thats just not fair...
i knew she'd get the rap, but REALLY, besides maknae doing sohee's part,
we didn't hear the other girls much.
did jihyun even SING?
i heard gayoon at the end, and a LITTLE bit of jiyoon but besides that....
not fair. not fair at all.
if not for maknae's part, really, it would have been more of a "hyuna ft. the other members of 4minute" performance.
i know it was just a cover, but still!

[Ayuumu]

Yes, they have really high expectations in the girls.....
4Minute is trying really hard and are improving a lot!!!
We just have to wait!

About Hyunah's voice I think it changed because see was young when she debut, in the other groups that have younger people they were/are changing voices too (like Sohee and Taemin).......

[*Lizzie*]

Welcome to the thread!!!!!!!

I just saw there MNet performance and I liked it. I understand some don't like Hyunah's voice but I love it. It's so different from others. She's not the same she was back then and a lot are hoping she gets that voice back. But anyhow, Jiyoon was so loud and clear on there Hot Issue performance and I love it. I couldn't see clearly, so I don't know if Maknae had a backpack this time or not.

On there Tell Me performance, I liked it. I wished they gave the rap part to Jiyoon cuz I want to hear her rap, but oh well and the leader should of gotten at least a part but she didn't. Anyhow, I thought that Maknae was so cute doing the Uh-muh~! Gayoon was amazing. Finally I get to hear Gayoon very clearly on a performance and it was awesome.

[FlowerofWisdom]

Welcome to the thread Ayuumu (and any other newbies)!

I expected some of the other girls to get more lines for "Tell Me" so I was kind of dissappointed when I saw their performance.

SoHyun did great with SoHee's parts.
GaYoon was pretty awesome to.
JiYoon rocked even though she didn't have that many lines.
As for Hyunah and JiHyun...I can't really say much about Jihyun since she didn't even have any lines other than that I wish they had given her at least one line. I know she's not the best singer in the group but hey could have at least given her one solo line or at least she could have done the solo dance break. Cube is really making it difficult for Jihyun and the other girls to shine.
I wonder why they keep giving Hyunah the most lines, I like her, but honestly her vocals are one of the weakest in the group. I expected them to give JiYoon and GaYoon the most lines since they're probably the two best vocalists (and maknae is up there to).
I thought Hyuna's voice was only high-pitched for the "hot issue" song but it was pretty high in this song to, I wonder if that is how she really sounds now.

[shirlyn]

Either I'm crazy or my ears went bad, but I thought 4Minute sounded great during the "Tell Me" performance? It definitely was different from the Wonder Girls that's for sure, but it was still good!

They gave Hyun Ah the rap and not Jiyoon because when Hyun Ah was actually a Wonder Girl that WAS her part so it makes no sense to give it someone else, and they couldn't give Jiyoon a big singing part because the song is too girly, and would it would ruin her "tomboy" image, in my opinion.

Original tell me with hyuna didn't include a rap bridge, thus the reason why the The Wonder Begins first version didn't include Yoobin's rap. It was made upon Yoobin's entrance to WG. i Think Hyunah had sunmi's first part...

i went to read the WG first thread and i hate comparisons but everyone kept saying hyunah was so much better than yoobin...i know it's not the problem, but...i really hate it if media started comparing them both again (and fans as well), yoobin and hyunah would be hurt ;_; and i don't want that...the past should be laid to rest. Hyunah did a wonderful work while on WG but that's the past, they were not nearly as popular back with her as they are now and it just feels as if she or her ent. company are trying to rip off a little attention for themselves to gain more popularity (even if they are already doing good on their own) by using hyunah's old role as a wonder girl...and why don't they use Irony, she DID use to sing that song so it's more understandable, but singing tell me? it seems fishy to me. Hyunah is in 4Minute now. Not WG. And she should make a new name for herself as a 4Minute member, not live under WG shadow as much as she regret or doesn't regret leaving the group, because she's just going to continue being know as the ex wonder girl member and not as 4minute member (as i already read in many news ''ex WG...member''. *sigh*

I hope at least that critics stop being so harsh to the girls for not 'performing' up to their expectations. I mean, it's not their song, they did an awesome job as it is already and should be clapped for paying a sort of tribute to their senior, and in hyunah's case, her friends.

4minute has already done a lot for being in scene for such little time! 4MIN! FIGHTING!

[~ cherrie ~]

Terrible capture I took but Hyunah looks cool lol
look at that 4minute ring ?

http://i44.tinypic.com/2rcwtj4.png

yup,my hyuna baby is hot..i agree on what shirlyn said.originally, hyuna was the singer for sunmi's part so i think her ent thought it would be better for her?.For every verse, they have to practice the song and see who is suitable to sing whose part so it's ok that hyuna gets more line since she originally sung more parts but poor leader ..I would love to see them singing Irony..I love that song.I've been hearing that song for 2 yrs..O.O
For the performance, their dance wasn't in sync but it's okay..4min <33

[xjleex]

More Pictures!

Credits to bobo@4minute forums
From 4-minute's fancafe.

[yumoreo5]

I like this group, they're cute and do have the potential of improving but at the moment, they're not really living up to their funky flashy trendy clothes. I totally love their fashion statement but their voices are so-so. I want to hear them sing a ballad or something since these poppish songs aren't really good at capturing voices.