[Mishxmish]

MBC '이미지 서바이벌' 출연자 이미지 실추 논란

[스포츠조선 2006-01-15 10:49]


프로그램 재미위해 '신인들 죽인다'
　'이미지 서바이벌'은 신인을 죽이는 프로그램?
　MBC '강력추천 토요일'의 새 코너 '이미지 서바이벌'이 출연자의 이미지를 실추시킨다는 비난 여론에 직면했다. 연예인들의 이미지 설문 조사 등을 통해 더욱 좋은 이미지를 만들어 나갈 기회를 주자는 기획 의도와 정반대의 결과.

　사실상의 첫 희생양은 수퍼주니어의 강인인 듯하다. 14일 방송이 나간 직후 강인은 선배 연예인들에게 막말을 하는 예의 없는 후배인 것처럼 연출돼 순식간에 포털 사이트의 조회수 상위에 오르내리며 도마에 올랐는가 하면 안티 카페까지 생겨날 정도로 곤경에 처했다. 강인의 팬들은 이에 모든 원인이 프로그램의 재미를 위해 신인을 희생시키며 무리한 설정과 멘트를 하도록 유도한 제작진과 진행진에게 있다며 흥분하고 있다.

　문제의 장면은 조혜련, 신지, 김창렬과 강인이 자리에 없는 연예인을 놓고 '뒷담화'를 나누는 대목. 조혜련과 신지, 김창렬 등이 해당 스타의 뒷이야기를 주도하면서 옆에서 듣고 있던 강인으로 하여금 한 술 더 뜨도록 유도, 결과적으로는 강인이 선배를 헐뜯는 것처럼 보이게 함으로써 연예계 선배들이나 시청자들에게 욕을 먹을 수 있는 상황이 만들어졌다.

　이미지 서바이벌이 초반부터 암초에 부딪힌 가운데 일각에서는 '이미지 꽝' 연예인을 뽑는 설정 자체가 해당 연예인이나 팬들에게는 기분 좋을 리 없는 만큼 이참에 중간 점검을 하고 새롭게 재정비하는 것이 좋을 것 같다는 의견도 내놓고 있다. < 정경희 기자 gumnuri@>



- Copyrights ⓒ 스포츠조선, 무단 전재 및 재배포 금지

This is an article that came out today about Kangin and the Show Image Survival.

Title: For the popularity: Kill the Rookie


The first paragraph talks about:
MBC made the show purposely for Stars to upgrade their image to the viewers through gradual appearance on Image Survival.

The second Paragraph:
The first victim is a member of Super Junior; KangIn. After the video air on the 14th, KangIn has been shown on television to be the disrespectul individual with no acceptance of seniority. Within moments Kangin was all over the internet and even a anti cafe was about to be made. KangIn's fans are blaming the show for making KangIn come out unpleasing to the viewers for the sole purpose of show's popularity.

The third paragraph:
The problem took place with ChoHyeLyun, ShinJi, and Kim ChangLyun. KangIn was placed in a position where he had to be listening for awhile and speak up for his image. However, this portrayed a negative image because he was depicted so that KangIn would be cursed at by the viewers.

Last Paragraoph:
It just says how the show which picks stars by their image because it is supposedly "bad" should be a diss to the viewers/fans and the stars. So the show image survival is actually thinking about ending and starting something different.


[my opinion]
i was actually on Kangin's Cyworld awhile ago and a lot of fans put up encouraging words, but then many people put up some very horrible messages too... And at the end of it all... i am not sure if it realli was kang in or not, but he posted up a message that said: What is all this nonesense...

I realized kangin's fnas were trying realli hard not to be mean but as you read on.. the fans started to get annoyed by the anti's and started cursing too... so i think kangin tried to stop it.. but it can be some stupid idiot playing a jooke and acting like KangIn.. i felt so bad because 90% of what is shown on image survival is all on scripts... He never cursed and many people are saying he did.... Basically they were having like a talking i can't read corner and whatever the rest of the people said slided and what kangin Said became full blown. I mean they could have edited his part and then cut it out or something... its not even a live show.. they made it purposely for KangIn to look like that...

Oh yea and guess what it is: Kang In's Birthday!

영운오빠
힘내세요^^
오빠옆에는
우리가잇어요
누가뭐라하던간에
옆에서지켜줄게요^^
생일도얼마안남앗는데
웃으면서넘기자구요^^

생일축하해요♡


This is taken from KangIn's cyworld...

으컁컁ㅋ : 김영운화이팅♡(01.15 00:00)
dfd : 솔직히 아무 팬도아닌 저로써 보기에도 강인이 너무 심했습니다(01.15 00:06, IP : 220.230.171.32)
진짜 : 근데 왜 여기다 올리냐고 다른데 많잖아 여긴 개개인의 공간이야 개티즌아(01.15 00:08, IP : 222.239.17.52)
김보람 : 근데 리플에다가 무슨짓이냐고!!! (01.15 00:16)
박한울 : 그럼 떳떳하게 로그인하고 글 쓰세요....비난아닌 비판은 저희도 수용할 수 있으니깐요.(01.15 00:26)
dfd야 : 나도 너 모르는 사람으로써 네가 너무 심해 임마(01.15 00:38, IP : 221.141.219.99)
이은주 : - - ↑ 여기서 이러지마세요 ,(01.15 00:48)
박미진 : 다들 로긴 해라 아이피 추적 하기 전에 ㅋㅋㅋㅋ 다 시켜서 한거래매 - - 왜 시킨 사람들은 욕을 안먹는거지? ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ(01.15 01:22)
남서리 : 로그인하고 글을 쓰세요 ~ - -(01.15 02:04)
신주형 : 거기서 욕한사람이 강인만 있어 ? ㅡㅡ 왜 조혜련이랑 개네는 욕 안해 ㅅㅂㄴ들아 괜히 강인한테만 그래 (01.15 03:22)
손소정 : 왜들이러세요ㅜㅜ(01.15 04:39)
fdgdg : 거지같은년들 키키키키키키(01.15 09:23, IP : 220.230.171.32)
푸핫ㅋㅋ : 씨발..욕하지 말라고...(01.15 09:44, IP : 211.108.213.94)
류수경 : 떳떳하지못하니까.비회원으로 댓글다시는건가봐요. 참 위엣분들 보기좋습니다.^^(01.15 10:15)
지슬기 : 상대하지마세요.이런분들 팬들이 반응보이면 더 그래요.(01.15 10:30)
으컁컁ㅋ : 알았다고요 알았으니깐 빨리 비회원이든 로그인 하셨든 욕 다 지우고 가세요. 정말 보기 안좋습니다.(01.15 10:50)
김보미 : 강인이오빠한테머라하지마요ㅜㅜㅜ(01.15 10:59)
김보미 : 하고싶은말있음안티카페가시든가요-3-(01.15 11:00)
이소진 : 그만들 하시죠.(01.15 11:03, IP : 61.79.22.28)
곽나은 : 보기안좋아, 다지우세요.(01.15 11:13)
김민희 : 신인죽이는프로그램ㅡㅡ그프로그램이잘못했음.강인오빠화이팅ㅋㅋㅋ(01.15 11:21, IP : 211.219.227.106)
오윤희 : MBc모 방송 프로그램 짜증 강인님 완전 good!!(01.15 11:37, IP : 58.231.96.24)
김아리 : 위에 욕하시는분들.. 영운오빠는 사람도 아니랍니까- - ? 솔직히 지들도 뒷땅 다 까면서..니들이나 잘하세요^^(01.15 12:00)
fdfdf : 김아리 니나잘하지 ㅋㅋㅋㅋ찌질아(01.15 12:15, IP : 220.230.171.32)
으컁컁ㅋ : ↑니는뭐니?강인오빠보겠다^^ 빨리 지우고 꺼져~^^(01.15 12:19)
강인 : 뭐하는짓들인지..(01.15 12:23, IP : 211.199.172.150)
윤경 : 그냥 스타가되는 과정으로써 생각하죠 이미지서바이벌얘기 그만들꺼내세요 보기정말 안좋아요 같은팬으로써(01.15 13:35)

The red is Supposedly Kangin...



CREDIT to : Mish, Naver, & Junior Source

[Valeria]

I saw this episode and I can understand why netizens are scolding him right now. All the crap Kangin said about his sunbaes behind their backs was just unacceptable and disrespectful. I really hope he learns from this and watches what he says from now on. =/

oh and I think this should be posted in the SJ thread.

[lovelylil819]

What did he say that made he seem disrespectful?

**NVM...I skip a paragraph...haha. Well, I think people are taking it too seriously.

[kkam jjak]

i never liked him... especially after the image survival episode cuz i always got the image of him as a ssagajee but i dont hate him either... i'm just indifferent to him i guess

i admire ppl who are blunt but he was talkin so much crap behind those celebrity's backs in that episode... if he wouldve said it to their face i wouldve thought that he had a lot of guts for speaking his mind

btw any of u kang in fans.. dont bash me im just speaking my mind

[U-KNOW]

some people mentioned that this show is scripted ..
so i find this really stupid and viewers are taking it too seriously

[kkam jjak]

^Really? .. but he still gives off this cocky ssagajee image to me but i dont hate him.... am i making any sense?

[nessa]

what exactly did he say?

[TiFFaNiZeD]

what exactly does the show do??? i don't get it....

[~S2~]

i didnt think he was being bad at all

[Hoii]

some people mentioned that this show is scripted ..
so i find this really stupid and viewers are taking it too seriously

Exactly. It's scripted. If you're on the show, you don't exactly get much of a choice as to what you say. It's so foolish for people to get worked up over it. Who cares?

[Izzie]

edit:

some things Kang-In (aka 욕신) said:

SS501: Nothing. He said SS501 has too much fans.
Ryan: He uses his voice too much. He thinks he's that great. & "Does Paran have that much fans?"
No JungMyung (RedSox): "She actually thinks she's cute when you tell her that is. She calls Lee Kyung-Gyu oppa!"
Tei: "답답하죠"
And when he was going to be talked about, he left with a message of "Super Junior has a lot of fans too" a.k.a. "Watch what you say"


I left out lotsa stuff, but I thought these were the most important.
This was very disrespectful, and well, not surprised people are going crazy on him.

[*Binnie]

iono what happened, but i kinda feel bad for him.

[truexskills]

i just watched my first episode of image survivoir last night..and this came up so i was like whoa
im no tsure, but the one i watched had kangin in it..
could it be tha tone? or is it that kangin appears frequently?
beofre image survivor on the one i watched, there was this program where parkkyunglim woke up the members of ss501 in the morning..
please clarify
and yeah kangin does have the cocky/mean look to him, but i still colndier him my fav out of super junior

[AKIRADOWN]

edit:

some things Kang-In (aka 욕신) said:

SS501: Nothing. He said SS501 has too much fans.
Ryan: He uses his voice too much. He thinks he's that great. & "Does Paran have that much fans?"
No JungMyung (RedSox): "She actually thinks she's cute when you tell her that is. She calls Lee Kyung-Gyu oppa!"
Tei: "답답하죠"
And when he was going to be talked about, he left with a message of "Super Junior has a lot of fans too" a.k.a. "Watch what you say"


I left out lotsa stuff, but I thought these were the most important.
This was very disrespectful, and well, not surprised people are going crazy on him.

but isn't it just for the show?? not likehe really meant it but it could have been also liek in xman ppl always dissing other peopel i don't see anything wrong with it...

[hillz3388]

what is this ahow all about anywayz..am so lost right now..

so hes been aacused of cursing on the show n being disrespectful?
*scratches head* but i dontsee why he is getting all the blame since its a script show? right,,?

[nessa]

hmmm what he said was kind of offending to the other stars, and plus he's younger than them too.

Dang, all of the threads I read, they didn't translate what he said about Tei, I wanna know! lol.

Thanx tho Izzie for the translations of what he said.

[BendyStraw]

so the show basically just bashed him? >.> so the new trend is to start drama where it isnt needed? hooray...

[Valeria]

Kangin got in trouble with SM because of what he said on image survival so its obvious the crap talking he did on the show was not in the script. I don't think SM would've allowed him to say those things if they knew beforehand that was what he had to say.

[happy.birthday]

i didnt think he was being bad at all

I agree. He was just saying the truth. I agreed with him all the way. Ryan does use his voice too much, sounding like Bi and I hate it when he acts like he is soo cool. and that other girl tries to be cute too when shes not.

Im not a Kangin fan, but I liked him on the show because he made it entertaining.

[june1ov3]

ohhhman i didn't watch thisss but i have it downloadedd.
but like people can't take it personally because this show is ALL script too.
EVERY show is by script and the stars have to follow thatt; so probably just to be funny or somethinggg; the show made a mistake and chose kangin to talk badd crap about otherss; but it's all script.
i hope this show doesn't get cancelled; i think image survival is so fun and funny =)