[mandi_]

ooooh! thanks mizzqtpnai for the link!!

wow i love the stage haha watching it now..

[dreamloverShiWon]

I'm waiting for the video to finish loading and I've watched a bit of the video. They're both wearing the same outfit as last week?? Haha... I agree the stage setting is quite impressive.

Edit:
I wish Junsu would sing louder... cause sometimes it sounds like JRI is singing on her own. Her start was BAD... She really has to keep working on her volume control... there were parts where she reminds me of Celine Dion (no offense to her fans). Celine is a prime example of bad volume control ie loud then soft, then suddenly would start screaming.

I'm kinda disappointed she didn't really improve as much as I would like her to, and she's less nervous too.

To end on a positive note, Xiah was fab!! His voice and looks blow me away.

Edit2:
I listened to the performance without looking at the screen, just to see how she compared with herself in the mp3.. Surprisingly she sounded better than when I'm watching the perf.. so I'm extremely confused. I still think she was screaming from the middle of the song onwards, but I think it's because Timeless is just such a hard song to sing. Next thing SM should choose a song that fits in her vocal range better.

[mandi_]

i just finished watching!! OMG it's SO MUCH better. im so excited!! She sounded waaaay more confident and louder! Before she was singing so softly compared to the mp3, you know in the mp3 how she overpowers him? In here you can hear that she has the voice that CAN overpower him, her voice is a lot stronger than other performances. I do agree that its still really shaky but in terms of what she needs to work on i think that's the only major thing! =D Plus she still looks like its really..painful for her to sing lol it sort of detracts from her good singing especially since Xiah's putting sooo much emotion and she's just.singing. once she puts more emotion into the song it'll be a GREAT performance!!

and the last 'timeless' is getting there..lol yay go Jang ri in!

i loved loved the stage! how they're on different levels so good!

[silentxtears]

Or over here
http://blog.daum.net/0228011/6531979

so it doesn't load as slow (I think)

[l33mimi]

She sounds the same as last week. I don't know is it because shes still nervous?

Cause i know that she can do better than this. Towards the middle where all the action

came in, she couldn't go up, u can hear the background sound. -__-;

[Lene]

i love and hate the stage setting. i think it's cool that there's a huge "timeless" there but both junsu and jang ri in are so far apart. argh.
Anyway, she's getting better. Best performance so far. But she's still quite stiff on stage. She need to move more. As for her vocals, many have already said what are her weak points but honestly, i give her major props. Beautiful voice for such a hard song. <3

[MinwooLicious]

hermm.. she's still sounds shaky to me ...
but its a good sign .. at least she moves and showed us some facial expression than juz stand straight like her last 2 perf.
she absolutely can do better than that .. timeless really is a tough song
phuih..... i LOVE love the stage ..wahaha..nice set up ... and Junsu is gettin hotter n hotter .. ahah.. looks like his hair colour is changing or it juz because of the lightning ... he sang soo gewd ~~
nevertheless .... Riin Chaiyo' !! Junsu Hwaeeting !!
prays that they will get mutizen next week .. :)

[YELL;OH]

ah, the inkigayo performance!
besides a couple shaky parts (which were very minor) she did so well~~ xD

i swear, my favorite part of this song is
"내 손 잡아요
떠나지 말아요"

i`m always like all =O during that part... dunno why, i just love it ;P

[qweqwe]

Just finished watching her Inkigayo perf, not trying to be mean or anything, but she has a knack of starting off really shaky now..and many of ner notes in the middle were wavery and forced. Other than that, she held herself better this time overall, she's improving. Especially on that last "this is timeless" that she always dies at, she didn't perfect it [still off at the beginning], but it was much better this time and not as..deafening. At least she's slowly getting better with each performance, although I think she should try to look a little less..pained when she sings. It just makes it all the more forced looking, and it doesn't help her voice. Hope she keeps improving, and I'll be waiting to see the Music Wave performance~

on a side note, Junsu was still perfect ^^

Hi reminiscencex!

Do you know when the music wave in which Junsu & Riin perform in will be out? I have been hearing about it but have no idea when it will be aired.... Thanks!

[angel2nyt]

she did much MUCH better with her performance
from the first note, it was obvious that she wasnt that nervous anymore.. i enjoyed this perofrmance more than her previous two.. in the middle of the song.. sometimes she would have those sharps and sometimes it would sound forced but she is improving

lol..when i saw that timeless thing on the stage. the first thing that came through my mind was 70's disco(for some odd reason)

[the EEL]

i got all excited when i saw the posts about her "improvement"... but then when i watched it i was really let down.

to be super blunt, i think she was almost as off and shaky as her other performances and i agree with the few people who said she still needs more work. at first i thought that maybe she was just not a good singer but then i saw a fancam of their rehearsal and she sounded FINE... almost identical to the mp3. if she could only get over her nerves everything would be gravy but i feel she's getting off to a really bad start.

junsu was awesome like always but anyone notice that even his part was a little offkey? tone/strength/voice was great but something....i don't know... (who can blame him though, he just came from doing a concert in thailand)

TOTALLY looking forward to music wave though... the clips from fancams are such a tease~

[sakura_drop]

hmmm jsut finished watching todays performance and i got to say it the best performance out of the three she has done ............... she is slightly improve but yeha she still is a bit shaky in the middle parts of the song but yeah i guess she will improve more after more performance. She is like stiff on stage she need more expression or something when she;s singing
but i liek the stage today with the huge TIMELESS sign it looks awesome and Junsu as always is amazing and he jsut gets hotter and hotter

[yongwonhi]

The "Timeless" sign looks kinda funny. Haha. :X And what's up with them being so far apart? ;;

Moving on.... I didn't like her first "timeless." It didn't sound right.. x__x Hm, it was overall better, but I get the feeling they turned up her mic volume so you could hear her better... and so her voice overpowered Xiah's.

She still needs voice control. x__x I dunno though, I don't really like this performance. Something about it bugs me...

I applaud her though; Timeless is REALLY hard to sing! I remember hearing Kelly & Justin sing it, and Kelly messed up too...

XIAHH<3 sounds the exact same everytime. :X PERFECT! Puahahha.....

(I wanna hear her sing Y live!)

[mandi_]

Edit2:
I listened to the performance without looking at the screen, just to see how she compared with herself in the mp3.. Surprisingly she sounded better than when I'm watching the perf.. so I'm extremely confused. I still think she was screaming from the middle of the song onwards, but I think it's because Timeless is just such a hard song to sing. Next thing SM should choose a song that fits in her vocal range better.

haha i noticed that too. I think its just because on screen she looks like its reall painful for her to sing it so it doesn't make you enjoy the performance and gives you more of a negative impression overall. If you just listen to her voice..ignoreing the shakiness that im sure she'll be able to control soon enough, its actually pretty good. she has an awesome voice.

[ah_po]

people, you should really stop judging her about how she can't control her voice and stuff. she's still new, she's still nervous, and she's singing with junsu. give her a break, i know SM made her sounded really good but no one is perfect, specially since she's under all the pressure. she'll get better over time. ^______^

[angel2nyt]

Jang Ri In (Zhang Li Yin) + Xiah Junsu - 'Timeless' Performance in SBS Inkigayo Youtube Link:
http://youtube.com/watch?v=yRrrYeAE1yI

To download: http://z10.invisionfree.com/ZhangLiYin/ind...hp?showtopic=56

[eiskaffee]

thanks for posting the link.before i saw the perf.i read all your guys comments,i was wondering how she did ,you said "still shaky,still nevours,etc"and then i saw it ,i was surprised ,really,how could some of you still say disappoint ,i dare to say if this was her debut ,you will say something totally different.only because she'snot perfect on her debut ,so you have always a thought in your mind
"she isnot good as it said". i like her perf!!!it's GREAT! what do you expect for her, a kelly ? a chirstina? don't forget they are borned in usa, they have different voice and way to sing a song.can you name a female singer who's born in asia which's so young as jangriin and who can sing better than her???
i will surpport her on matter what you say.

[xmichellee]

I just finished watching the perf. I think she did better in this performance.

But why are both of them standing so far from each other. Lol.

Anyway, i can't wait to watch her next performance.. <3

[iluxxx]

^ hahaha. exactly~ so far apart!

i just watch her recent perf on youtube as well. and i must say she gets better and better each time. although she started off rather shaky and all, but she becomes constant after awhile. at least not much mistakes compared to her first perf, she'll get better~ i think it's just a matter of whether she feels comfortable on stage or not. please break through that obstacle!

[XiaoHei]

Hmm..I think the performance is really the best out of the three.
Just finished watching it.Lolz.
She sounded greater this time although she is still shaky.
And I don't think that she is screaming.
I don't see or hear that she was screaming though.
She is improving performance by performance.
She looked quite confident..Don't you think so?
And she had alot of expressions compared to previous performance.
She moved herself too.I mean..she was moving.Lolz.
She didn't really move alot previously.She was like standing there like a statue.
I think she is getting comfortable with the stage already.
As time goes by..I think she can be just as calm as Junsu.
Anyone realise she changed something in this song....
Erm...the part ''this is timeless..love...'' before the ''yeah~'' part.
She changed the ''love''.I found it cute!Lolz.
I love her performance.

Frankly speaking..if you expect her to sing exactly like the cd..
Why not just listen to the cd and don't waste your time watching her performance...
If you want her to sing exactly like the cd..why don't you expect her to lipsync?
Lipsync is definitely 100% exactly like the cd.
What is the point watching Live performances then?

Live performances are not perfect.Live is something we cannot hear in the cd.
For me..I'm expecting something different from the cd when I am watching Live performance.
As least the artist sang Live.This is a way of respecting us as audiences.
I'm not saying that lipsync artist is not respecting us.
I know and I understand they have their own reasons to lipsync.
Sorry if I had said something you don't like.
This is just my opinion.

Overall..she did quite well.Obviously..she is really improving.
Can't wait for more!
Lolz.The stage is funny.Muahahaha.
That huge Timeless..It sure cost alot of money.
SM is rich!Hahahaha~