[idealise]

Personally, I think Kelly did a lot better overall. Just generally, her voice was less shaky (Li Yin's vibrato live is totally out of control), and she hit most of the high notes with a lot of control, except towards the end where she lost it. To put it harshly - at least Kelly was in control all the way till the second chorus, while Li Yin lost it from the start.

I'm hoping Li Yin's Music Wave performance will be better than the ones so far, and I'm hoping she performs Y too! I have a feeling she'll do better on that song than Timeless.

[snoopy]

Kelly and Justin's Timeless peformance was ok but 2 be honest i think JRI sang it better than Kelly, she kinda had a hard time singin it as well.. As 4 Justin... junsu sang MUCH better (no offence)!
People might think that Kelly sang better than JRI but thats coz we are comparin JRI 2 the MP3 single whereas Kelly and Justin had only ever performed it live.. Right?

...but that's what a true artist is. able to sing well in live than sing well in MP3 single since you can adjust and make things sound better through audio mp3s. but live, it's coming straight from your voice and nothing with technologies that can help make the voice sound better. so...my vote has to go with kelly. even though she did kind of lose it towards the end, she still had that powerful voice and knew how to control her vibrates.

but i must agree with you about Junsu. Junsu is way better.

[xiahukno]

i still really like jang ri in... but i DONT understand...

why can she NEVER stay in tune at the very end of love? i mean... she has the music AND xiah to harmonize with... cant she tell if she's out of tune? i have NEVER heard her sing that note in tune. even in rehearsals. whats up with taht?!

nonetheless, she has improved A WHOLE LOT!

[Mabe]

Snoopy Thats what i mean..

MP3 single since you can adjust and make things sound better through audio mp3s. but live, it's coming straight from your voice and nothing with technologies that can help make the voice sound better

Thats why JRI isnt as good as the record because they can adjust it 2 sound better.. And were comparin her live vocals 2 her record..

Maybe im not explainin myself 2 well.. Im not 2 good with my words

But anyway yeh Junsu muchies better than Justin:)

Edit:
Oh i get what ur sayin now!!
hahaha i can be slow @ times

[mandi_]

i still really like jang ri in... but i DONT understand...

why can she NEVER stay in tune at the very end of love? i mean... she has the music AND xiah to harmonize with... cant she tell if she's out of tune? i have NEVER heard her sing that note in tune. even in rehearsals. whats up with taht?!

yeah i kno u'd think that SM would have worked with her on that last note just practicing and practicing..how hard would it be to teach her to sing that note in tune?

[angel2nyt]

does anyone have the mp3 verison to timeless?

i do.. just pm me if you need the mp3
multimedia sharing is prohibited in this forum

I'm hoping Li Yin's Music Wave performance will be better than the ones so far, and I'm hoping she performs Y too! I have a feeling she'll do better on that song than Timeless.

i have SSSSOOOO much expectations for why
i love that song more than timeless


people calm yourselves
it was just her third time performing.. yet she is a lot better than other singers who are more veteran than her

[lo0say]

i saw her inkigaya performance for last night

she's definitely improving so much

her voice is a lot stronger and she's less nervous

she had more emotion in it, and she looks more relaxed

Jang Li Yin Hwaiting

o yeh i love how the stage is set..............with all the different platforms and heights

[OoMaOci27oO]

yeah i kno u'd think that SM would have worked with her on that last note just practicing and practicing..how hard would it be to teach her to sing that note in tune?

It's also the most memorable tune too since it's at the very end, that's what you'll remember. I'm sure they notice it, hope they're working her! I still say give her time to improve.

[suejin115]

i like jri's version of timeless better, but i think kelly has a stronger voice. kelly has a more thicker warmer sound. but i still like jri better

[yongwonhi]

Kelly and Justin's Timeless peformance was ok but 2 be honest i think JRI sang it better than Kelly, she kinda had a hard time singin it as well.. As 4 Justin... junsu sang MUCH better (no offence)!
People might think that Kelly sang better than JRI but thats coz we are comparin JRI 2 the MP3 single whereas Kelly and Justin had only ever performed it live.. Right?

haha, nope... kelly and justin recorded it too. :] if anyone wants it, pm me?

and in the recorded version... kelly's voice flows better, and sounds... softer? XD but i like zly's version too.. i heard the korean timeless first, so when i heard kelly&justin, i didn't really like it. but then i listened to it a few times and i like it too. ; i <3 kelly clarkson, so yeah hahaha. but if you compare the kelly's mp3 to live, ...it's definitely better in the mp3. o_O; so zly sang really well live. yeap. i'm not even making any sense. = =;;
xiah sounds better than justin.

[love<3changmin]

i totally support her,
she definately improved in yesterday's perf..
tho its just a slight improvement, we should give her more time
we shudnt expect too much from her
i almost can feel the stress she's facing, being on top of charts, doing live perf on the age of 16, trying to sing as best as she could, ppl cheering mostly for her duet partner junsu...
well thts my opinion, i'll keep supporting her coz she needs alot!

[mayz]

I love Zhang Li Yin!! She's the first female singer I love soo much. In the past I tried to listen to some female singers from Cpop, Kpop, Jpop.. none I really love until now!! Jang Ri In! Love her voice alot.. so strong and captivating.. ^^

[Jin91]

whens music wave? she's gonna be on it right?

[Mabe]

^ 22nd Sept
Cant wait!! She'll most likely sing 'Why' since Junsu performed 'Beauitful thing'..

[xkrnbebe]

her performance was a lot better.. she's definitely improving with each performance... i didn't really like the set.. hehe they were so far apart from each other =/ can't wait for her music wave performance ^^

[kakahead]

i saw her for the first time on inkigayo~
and whoa i love her voice =D
she ish really pretty~
pretty eyes! =D

[shortyxP]

i love her song >.<
shes not that pretty buh i gotta admit her voice is amazing
i envy her.

[~neh~long~]

argh... i hope she performs timeless again w/ junsu... in my opinion i think she should keep going with timeless... although i love Y, i think it's a lot harder on her because she would be performing by herself... and she still needs to practice a bit? i want her to do well on timeless first and then move on to the next song >< maybe performing by herself will help her improve.... not sure =__=;; oh well, she'll have to perform without junsu eventually... but he really did help her out, i'm glad she did her debut perfs with him ^0^

[dankyung]

yea that one performance with kelly amd justin was the weakest i've ever seen from kelly. but i prefer kelly's version over jangriin. i dunno like i LOVE jangriin to death but wen it comes to that song i prefer the original O.o

[lo0say]

^ 22nd Sept
Cant wait!! She'll most likely sing 'Why' since Junsu performed 'Beauitful thing'..

yay.........can't wait

and she's going to sing "y"?

that's so cool

hopefully she'll do well on that song

it doesn't seem as hard as timeless, but it's still pretty difficult