QUOTE(TrungyBoi @ Oct 17 2006, 03:44 PM)

I disagree. Brett Farve won the super bowl without an all-pro WR, and Donovan McNabb has the highest winning percentage among active QBs despite having an all-pro WR for just two years of his short career (and let's not forget, in one of those seasons, that WR only played four games). I think a playmaker is a player who makes everyone around them better, and not just a player who is as good as the players he has.
It isn't about his athletic abilities. It is about his overall game. Vick is a good QB.. a solid one.. but what makes him different from a Brett Farve, another QB who has a gifted arm, is the fact that Vick is not aggressive enough with him passing. He opts to run than to squeeze in his passes. True, having a good receiver helps a player make those throws more often, and true, having one of the best runners in the game scramble for yards is better than throwing a risky pass, but letting Vick run inhibits Vick to be what he suppose to be.. a quarterback.
#2? #2 what? Young was picked third by the Titans.
How can you be a Cardinals fan in Pennsylvania? You should either be an Eagles fan or a Steelers fan (ew).

QUOTE(Love_Peanut @ Oct 17 2006, 06:24 PM)

Sorrie for jumping in the convo if this comment doesnt go along with anything but im in love with drew brees. I'm from New Orleans and at first i was so skeptical bout brees. i was thinking can this guy even throw and he changed me im a believer. He's up there with my all time fav qb peyton manning. Brees can lead a team. I'm so glad the Saints are actually winning. We're actually number one in the south division.
yes, brees has given me some proof that the saints can play, but they are heading into the tough part of their schedule
im not saing their bad, but they played two horrible teams in the first 2 weeks, the reopening of the dome had so much excitement and that gave the saints a huge emotional edge, which along with the falcons' mediocre playing (more like saints shutting them down) and they won against atl. they pulled one out against the eagles, but they have to do that for the nxt 7-8 games if they wanna make the preseason. but what can i say, they're 40 percent there..
the point of the qb is to lead the team and to get down the field for drives. how can you expect to fit it in small spaces if you have no faith that ur receivers iwll be able to catch it, but on the other hand, you know that you have a second card to play: your feet. he knows his feet can bail him in most situations and if he feels that his receiver can't make the catch, he'll just opt to run it. you think favre is all that great because he never ran it and was forced to make completions into tight spaces? why bother running if you have average-below average feet to run around in comparison to blazing feet? favre would have known that the chances of his receiver making the tough catch would probably be a higher percetnage attempt then him running around/through defenders with his feet, which is why brett probably chose to throw it, but vick knows that the chances that his receivers will bring it in for 10 yards or more is less of a chance than him gaining some yards or possibly even more with his feet, so he chooses to run it. so what? one thing i have noticed is that vick doesn't make those electrifying plays anymore (70-90 yard total juking/spin moves and making like 7 defenders miss on a run..) but in return, he plays a lot smarter and chooses to throw it more with better accuracy than in the past..
however, i think that playin gsmarter is better for vick..he still gets those 15-20 yards with his attempts and the chances of him getting hurt are less..especially when he has more protection on his runs with his line rather than taking it all on his own down the whole field..
oh yeah. to the saints fan.
sorry but your satnis are going to get pummeled in the dome. no emotional advantage there..only the birds looking for some dirty revenge...only if you guys had a reopening of the superdome every week.then you guys would be totally beastly...and i think a lot of your success also has to do with the stepping up of colston and henderson...and bullocks and whoever your other safety was..they are nasty in the games..too bad bryan scott has to play now...he sucks!

surprisingly, horn is not the one whos gettin gall the spotlihgt, for he hasn' done much, but i think its deuce's behind the scenes work in the cover of bush's spotlight as well..he's got several tds haha
i also find it how many new qbs and star receivers don't have much chmesitry so far
t.o-bledsoe
ward-ben (aven't gotten it started yet)
horn-brees
keyshawn-delhomme (not sure..keyshawn has a couple tds..but with steve smith back, you can expect delhomo to force a lot of passes to smith again..im sure itll be a slight less now that he knos he has keyshawn who can catch as well...)
brooks-moss
art shell-jerry porter
vick-lelie (and all of his other receivers..who stink horribly)
plummer-walker (im not sure..you don' treally hear much about the denver passing game, but if he's producing numbers, he should be on highlights/news)
hasselbeck-branch/koren robenson (sp?) (last week was pretty good though..branch connected for 2 tds)
Too lazy to make another sig. Ill get to it..maybe.